Now, I could sum up the entire player in a few words (mainly expletives) and that would be the end of the review, but I’d prefer to a go a bit more in-depth than that.
The Package
It’s 64.6 MB for Windows. Which is a lot, when you compare it with stuff like Windows Media Player (WMP) and Winamp, which are less than half that size. The reason it’s so bloated, is that it’s got a lot of stuff riding piggyback.
QuickTime Player comes default. I don’t blame Apple for that, because .mov is their own codec. But I think that they should go the Microsoft way, and let iTunes run the entire show. Apple could save a few MB there. Then, they’ve got some useless stuff. Like the Bonjour service, which allows you to access other iTunes libraries, over the local network. Then, there’s the Apple Mobile Device service for iPhones and iPod Touches. Again, not a necessity. Despite all of this, the installation is pretty easy.
Mainly because they never bother to ask you before installing each of these.
Really, not everyone needs all of the features the iTunes package has to offer, so Apple could add a few check boxes here and there during the install, and then shift the blame off to dumb users who just click ‘Yes’ throughout the installation.
The Features
OK, so I’ve disabled the useless services, and taken care of everything. And then I start up iTunes. One thing you’re likely to notice when you start it up, is that, unlike WMP and RealPlayer, it doesn’t have a video-centric layout, with a large empty space in the middle. iTunes, as the name suggests, is mainly for songs.
In iTunes 8, by default, you’re greeted with the Grid layout. This is a nice touch they’ve added in this version – you can choose to sort by Artist, Album, Genre or Composer, and the items are arranged in a grid, with multiple rollover Album Arts in case of multiple results for one grid item. This is a good replacement for the Browser in the list view, where you can select songs by artist, album or genre in a dropdown box. The original list view is still there, and so is Cover Flow. Cover Flow, as you should know by now, displays the album art as if you’re browsing through a large collection, flowing from side to side.
Genius is a nice touch. It’s not groundbreaking, but at least it’s here in iTunes now. You can upload your music tastes, like ratings, to Apple’s servers, and you can download the cumulative results from Apple, which includes ratings from all over the world. If you select one song, and click on the Genius button, you can get a list of songs similar to your selection. Call it refined shuffle if you will…
Unfortunately, you need to create an iTunes Store Account for this, which is of no use in India, as there aren’t any songs for sale, only iPod Touch and iPhone applications. Still, I did give Mom’s credit card details over a secure(?) connection. The results are somewhat accurate. The iTunes Mini Store, has been integrated with the Genius sidebar, which recommends songs which go with the one you’re listening to, and recommends other top songs as well.
There’s a new visualiser. Apple’s apparently bought a visualiser called Magnetoshpere, and has made it one with iTunes. To be honest, I like it, even thought it hasn’t got too much variety, and the visualiser changes only when you change the song, or pause it. The good thing about it, is that it uses the graphics card, so it can deliver incredibly smooth animations, assuming your CPU is not bottlenecked either.
Apart from this, like older versions of iTunes, version 8 supports videos, podcasts and also radio. If you look around on the iTunes Store, you can find a selection of free podcasts, which aren’t all that bad. Also, Radio stations they’ve listed aren’t bad either.
There’s a problem, which has persisted ever since iTunes was released. iTunes can’t read most video files. It has to be in the few handful formats that it supports. Unlike WMP and RealPlayer, iTunes does not check up with the Operating System what all codecs are installed on the PC. It’s beacause WMP does this that it can play DivX files with ease. Feels more friendly too. But Apple won’t give in, and that makes iTunes suck.
Genius hasn’t ousted Party Shuffle, which lives on in the left sidebar. You can get it to randomly select songs from the entire library or a particular playlist, and also give preference to higher rated songs. iTunes supports smart playlists, like any other music player worth its salt. You can give multiple conditions to get results like all Coldplay songs with ratings of 4 or higher.
Even though there isn’t a way to directly convert songs to MP3 or change bitrate, there is a convoluted way to do that. Go to Edit -> Preferences, and click on the Import Settings button on the General tab. Then set your preferences, save them, right-click the song you want and select ‘Create MP3 version’.
iTunes also connects to the Gracenote CDDB online database for CDs, which allows you to download info about the songs on a CD. Speaking of CDs, iTunes can burn audio CDs, MP3 discs and Data discs.
The Performance
Going back to when I fired up iTunes for the first time.
It doesn’t exactly fire up.
It crawls half-heartedly. Taking up 50~60 MB when I first start it. Can fluctuate wildly. Plus, this is way too much, to listen to a song, or just grab a bit of a video, iTunes is impracticle. Useless, rather.
Scrolling through lists of songs can be a pain, but not browsing Cover Flow, for some reason. It stores the library in an XML file, and boy is it slow! Search is really stagnant, and it takes ages for iTunes to respond to a keystroke in the Search bar.
Videos are not smooth. Period. Of the few videos that iTunes can play, when you move the mouse over the video, a semi-transparent control overlay appears, which causes the video to jar till it disappears. iTunes remains the very worst player, when it comes to video playback.
When you connect an iPod, iTunes simply freezes up as the PC and the pod chat about a bit. No control at all. Luckily, the music doesn’t stop, or I’d be tempted to put my foot through the monitor.
Unfortunately, if Apple decided to release a minor update to version 8.0.1, you’ll be forced to download the whole thing again. All 65 MB of it! A rather huge pain in the ass.
Tags: Apple, iTunes, Reviews, Software